Several years ago a smart-looking young boy came to me and said, "Sir I am an Engineering College student. I have been reading the Bible for some time and have come to you to argue that that God does not exist. I heard you are an apologist, and also a physicist, so you and I can have a great time talking". I was happy to meet him, and welcomed him for a cup of coffee.
On the appointed day he visited me at my home, and was unusually
eager to talk. I once again asked him whether he was sure he wanted to
argue with me, and he said yes. I then asked if he would keep his
conversation strictly at the scientific level, seeing that is what he
said the day before. He said he would keep his arguments strictly at the
scientific level, and added that this would be the appropriate approach
seeing that he was an Engineering student and I that I had a physics
Without delay I invited him to present at least one experimental or
observational evidence that disproves God. He was suddenly possessed by
silence. In fact he was dumbfounded. He had read plenty of publications
written against God, and thought that these are all scientific
arguments, but when confronted to support his contention that he would
use science to argue against the existence of God, he was unable to
advance a single evidence.
He than asked me to list my reasons for belief in God, and that he would refute all of them. I asked him whether such a refutation would amount to a “scientific” proof that God did not exist. He paused for a few moments and then accepted that such refutation would not amount to a scientific proof that God does not exist.
I then reminded that right from the moment he sought me out, he had been working on the premise that he would “disprove” the existence of God using “scientific proofs”. After much silence he asked my leave for a few weeks after which he said he would surely come back to me with such arguments.
The young man never came back. I still wait for him. I wait for him in vain because nobody has proved that God does not exist, though plenty of people claim that science has disproved God. The ball still remains in the court of the so-called “rationalist”.